Let’s face it: Come November 1, you’re probably going to eat whatever candy your neighborhood’s trick-or-treaters didn’t nab. So if you’re watching your weight, what should you buy?

We asked a bevy of registered dietitians to give us the rundown on which sweets will be sweeter to our health. Their verdict: Snickers bars are healthier than Reeses Peanut Butter Cups, Peanut M & Ms are better than Skittles, and Kit Kats are healthier than Twix.

Check out our complete list of healthy Halloween candy choices.